Rationale:
The following pastiche will examine an article from Fox News regarding the Palestine-Israel conflict. This specific article shows clear favoring of the Israeli side and antagonizes the Palestinian side significantly. The pastiche will rewrite the article and change the bias to favor the Palestinian side. There will be vague information about the Israeli side and will only highlight and present the Palestinian side in a good light. The pictures in the two articles are also completely different seeing as the one on Fox News shows the Palestinian side as an evil side and the one on the pastiche shows the Israeli side as the bad side.
Original Article:
The following pastiche will examine an article from Fox News regarding the Palestine-Israel conflict. This specific article shows clear favoring of the Israeli side and antagonizes the Palestinian side significantly. The pastiche will rewrite the article and change the bias to favor the Palestinian side. There will be vague information about the Israeli side and will only highlight and present the Palestinian side in a good light. The pictures in the two articles are also completely different seeing as the one on Fox News shows the Palestinian side as an evil side and the one on the pastiche shows the Israeli side as the bad side.
Original Article:
From Fox News about Israel and Palestine- clearly favoring the Israeli side.
Israel's
parliament has passed a law toughening penalties against Palestinians for
throwing rocks at soldiers, after a nearly two-month wave of violence that has
seen almost daily Palestinian attacks on Israeli civilians and soldiers.
The law
places a minimum sentence of three years on offenders and strips rock-throwers
of their social security benefits, a punishment that applies to Palestinians in
east Jerusalem. The parents of minors convicted of rock-throwing could also
have their social security benefits annulled during the period of the
offender's sentence.
Israel's
parliament, the Knesset, announced passage of the law on its website Tuesday.
The legislation was first introduced months ago, before the current unrest
began.
On
Wednesday, Israel police say a Palestinian was shot and killed after he rammed
his vehicle into an officer in the West Bank. Police spokeswoman Luba Samri
says the officer was seriously wounded in the attack.
The
violence began with clashes at a sensitive Jerusalem holy site and quickly
spread across Israel and into the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Eleven Israelis
have died, mostly in stabbing attacks, while 70 Palestinians have been killed,
including 44 people labeled by Israel as attackers.
"A
minimum punishment is necessary to create a deterrent and uproot the assumption
that `it's just a stone,"' said lawmaker Nissan Slomiansky, who sponsored
the legislation. He said that "throwing a rock is an attempt to murder and
there should at least be a minimum punishment."
Arab
lawmaker Jamal Zahalka condemned the law, saying that "fires cannot be put
out with gas, and this law is throwing gas on a fire."
The
first fatality in the current round of violence was a 64-year-old Israeli who
died after his car was pelted with rocks in Jerusalem as he drove home during
the Jewish New Year.
Israeli
leaders have accused Palestinian political and religious leaders of inciting
the violence. The Palestinians say it is the result of frustration after nearly
50 years of Israeli occupation.
Modified Article:
As the Palestinian side continues
to defend itself against incoming attacks from soldiers, Israel’s parliament
passed yet more penalties against Palestinians, after nearly two months of
Palestinian defense against Israeli attacks.
The law takes away rights of the
citizens by stripping the fighters of their social security benefits. Young and
helpless children could also be punished because the parents will be penalized.
The Knesset, a parliament,
announced the law on Tuesday. Even though the legislation was introduced months
ago, Palestinians have only recently been facing heavy and unnecessary attacks
that require self-defense.
A Palestinian was brutally shot and
murdered on Wednesday. The Israeli police involved dealt with minor injuries.
The violence escalated at
Palestines holy site, Jerusalem and quickly spread to further occupied
territories. 70 Palestinians were murdered, 44 of them killed because they were
defending themselves. Some Israelis also died.
“We will defend ourselves against these
unrightful laws designed to strip our people of their rights” said spokesman
Mohammad Khalid. He also said that “rock throwing is one of the few ways the
Palestinians can defend themselves”
Israeli lawmaker condemned the law
and said that, “fire needs to be put out with water, and this law only throws
water on fire”.
In this escalating violence, an old
Israeli man died after his car interacted with several Palestinian fighters. On
the other hand, 12 Palestinians died the same day from incoming fire from the
Israeli offense.
Palestinian leaders have accused
Israeli extremists and Zionists of inciting the violence and that this is
self-defense against more than 60 years of violence. The Israelis say that the rocks
are frustrating them.
Great job Amirah. You have done a good job portraying a conservative perspective regarding this sensitive topic. I believe that you have used the bias techniques in an efficient way and that can be easily and clearly identified such as "In this escalating violence, an old Israeli man died after his car interacted with several Palestinian fighters. On the other hand, 12 Palestinians died the same day from incoming fire from the Israeli offense."
ReplyDeleteAll in all you have done a great job.
I think this is a very successful attempt at writing an article from your mentioned perspective. Your word choice is very good at evoking certain responses and allows you to focus on certain messages. I especially liked the idea of using images to enforce your ideas and draw the reader's attention visually. The length of sentences also lends to your establishment of bias. Overall its a great article, well done! :)
ReplyDelete